Their Second Taste

Their Second Taste

An original true story by Starrynight.

Thanks to Brian for sharing his story with me and to Hisnhers for reading it and helping improve it.

It is highly recommended that you read the first part of the story first, Their First Taste.

Brian breathed heavily, panting as he looked down at his younger sister covered in his cum. His friends were talking and moaning next to them, admiring the intensity of the taboo act as they touched themselves, but Brian barely heard a word of it, his entire focus on his younger sister as their eyes stayed locked.

“Oh my god!” Beth let out, her chest rising and falling with her labored breathing as a grin tugged at her lips. “That was…” Beth started saying, looking up into her brother’s eyes and he returned a satisfied grin.

“I know,” Brian said, smiling down at his sister, then he leaned down and pressed his lips to hers. He kissed her, kissed his sister passionately, then pulled up and looked deep into her eyes from just inches away, feeling her warm breath on his. He studied her for just a moment, studied his beautiful sister’s face, then moved down her body and started kissing her neck.

Brian’s cock went soft, but his hunger for his younger sister was stronger than ever as he began to kiss her naked body tenderly. He kissed her neck, nuzzling it, then moved down her body. He pressed his warm lips to her chest, her smooth skin warm and inviting, and slowly made his way down to her delectable breasts.

Beth’s breasts were covered with her brother’s cum, but Brian didn’t seem to care, quite the opposite, and as his mouth moved to her tits, he stuck his tongue out and licked a glob of cum from her. Beth watched her brother’s tongue dart out, scooping up his cum, then swallowing it, and she let out a shivering moan. “Fuck Bri!” she moaned silently as she watched her brother scoop up more of his cum from her left nipple, using his tongue to rub it along her areola teasingly, then he swallowed it before closing his lips around her erect nipple and sucking on it to her delight.

“Fuck, that’s so hot!” Kelly whispered to Jimmy and Tom as all three watched Brian lick his cum off his sister’s naked body. Kelly moaned, her fingers rubbing her needy clit, and the guys stroked their hard cocks on both sides of her. They were all so horny, Kelly’s pussy soaking wet, but they were also too engrossed by Beth and Brian to do anything other than masturbate as they watched.

“Ugh, Brian!” Beth moaned as her brother continued to lick his cum from her. She watched, her arousal skyrocketing as her older brother cleaned her up with his sly tongue. He started on her breasts, kissing them, sucking on her erect nipples, and licking them clean. He raised his head after he finished licking them, grinning at her as he licked cum off his lips, then continued down her naked body, cleaning the rest of her off.

Brian could feel the blood start to rush back to his dick as he continued to lick his cum off his sister. He went at it with a ferocious hunger, pressing his lips to her smooth skin as he moved down her stomach, using his tongue to lap up his cum all the while. He moved lower, licking the last of his cum from her smooth vulva, then, when she was clean, he moved between her legs. Brian gave his sister’s seductive slit a few teasing licks, getting another taste of her delicious flavor, then straightened himself up. He offered Beth his hand, helping his sister up, and once she was sitting, Beth grabbed her brother’s head and pulled him in for a passionate kiss.

Brian and Beth moaned into each other’s mouths as they started making out. They were so hungry for each other, the initial reluctance a thing of the past, and it didn’t take long for Beth to shove her tongue into her brother’s mouth. She moaned into his mouth, the salty taste of his cum driving her mad, and she soon pulled her tongue away only to have Brian slide his tongue into her mouth. They made out for some time, eagerly devouring each other as their hands played with their exposed bodies. Beth reached for her brother’s cock as they continued to kiss, her nimble fingers tugging on his growing member, and by the time they were out of breath and broke the kiss, Brian was hard.

“Ready to go again?” Beth asked her brother with a devious grin, still tugging on his erection.

“Uh-huh,” Brian said nodding, a horny smile on his face, and he pressed his mouth to Beth’s for a final taste. His sister smiled at him, a naughty expression on her pretty face, then she let go of his dick and watched it throb. She ran a hand along her brother’s exposed chest, then turned around and got on all fours facing away from him.

“Fuck me big brother!” Beth called to him, her voice rasped and dripping with arousal. She wiggled her tight little ass seductively, and a moment later his hands grabbed her ass and started squeezing it.

“Are they gonna fuck again?” Kelly asked with disbelief and arousal, still rubbing her pussy as she watched Brian taking his place behind his sister.

“Fuck that’s so hot!” Jimmy called out next to her as he continued to stroke his dick. They all watched as Brian then spread his sister’s ass apart, then grabbed his shaft and guided it to her pink pussy. He pressed the head between her tight lips, making Beth whimper, then slowly pushed his hard cock into her hot snatch.

“Yes, Bri!” Beth moaned as her brother penetrated her from behind, sliding his cock once more into her forbidden hole. “Yes big brother!” she moaned as he found his way inside her, pushing inch after inch of his hard cock inside, going in so deep until his lower stomach was pressed to her tight ass.

“Ugh god!” Brian moaned as his sister’s pussy engulfed his hard cock so perfectly. “Fuck, my sister’s pussy feels amazing!” he moaned kinkily. He squeezed her ass once more, making Beth moan, then slid his hands to her waist, grabbed it, and started fucking her slowly.

Kelly watched Brian sliding his cock in and out of his sister’s wet cunt, starting slow and gradually picking up speed. She kept touching herself shamelessly as she watched the two, watching the way Beth’s pink muff took in her brother’s shaft, her lips engulfing him eagerly as the two moaned and groaned. She glanced over to her left, watching Jimmy tugging on his hard dick, then to her right, and looked at her boyfriend doing the same. She looked back at Brian and Beth just as Beth moaned, calling out her brother’s name, and it was all too much.

“Babe, stick it in me!” Kelly said to Tom in a pleading voice and turned to look at him stroking his monstrous shaft. “I need you inside me so bad!” Kelly begged, her arousal almost maddening, and she turned on her knees, her back to Tom. She turned her head towards Brain and Beth, watching Brian continue to fuck her harder, his balls slapping against his sister’s clit, then her pussy quivered as she felt her boyfriend take his place behind her, felt him align his big cock between her legs, then press it to her lips. She felt the anticipation take hold of her, her cunt getting wetter, then she let out a satisfied moan as he pushed it in, stretching her pussy with his big hard cock.

“Fuck!” Tom moaned as he pushed his hard cock into Kelly’s soaking pussy, her cunt wetter than ever.

“Yes!” Kelly moaned as Tom breached her, still looking at Brian defiling his sister, then turned her head around and looked at Tom as he pushed himself inside her. He held himself inside her for a moment, feeling her pussy stretch around his dick, then he slowly pulled out and pushed back in hard, making Kelly whimper.

“Ugh fuck!” Jimmy moaned, looking from Beth to Kelly, watching one getting fucked by her brother and the other by her boyfriend right next to him. Her gaze turned to meet his and her eyes darted to his cock, watching him stroking it. He turned his gaze back towards Brian and Beth, listening to Beth moan as Brian started plowing her pussy harder, then turned back to Kelly and caught her gaze.

“Oh yes, fuck me, hard baby!” Kelly moaned as Tom continued to stretch her with his big hard cock. She looked at Jimmy, watching him start to masturbate faster, and their gaze met again. “Yes, pound my pussy!” Kelly moaned, staring right at Jimmy, and bit her lower lip, biting down a grin as Jimmy looked at her hungrily.

“Fuck Kel! You’re so wet!” Tom groaned as he thrust his dick into Kelly’s twat hard, reaching a hand around her. He grabbed her tits with both hands, still fucking her, and started fondling her sensually.

“Yes, Brian! Fuck me! Fuck your sister’s pussy!” Beth moaned as her brother continued to fuck her doggy style. She loved it, loved being on all fours as her brother mounted her, sliding his hard prick in and out of her wet snatch, going faster and faster. “Yeah, just like that!” She moaned as he fucked her hard, pounding her pussy with echoing thrusts.

“Oh god!” Brian moaned as he pounded his sister’s hot wet cunt. He tightened his grip around her and continued with a fierce passion, ramming his dick hard into her tight pussy. She moaned each time he thrust into her, their bodies slapping together, and he watched mesmerized as his cock pumped her pink hole, her ass jiggling on the impact each time.

“Brian!” Beth called out in ecstasy and mewled as she came hard on her brother’s cock. “Oh my god!” She whimpered, her legs shaking, and as Brian shoved his cock back into her, her pussy convulsed, and she squirted onto the floor. “Fuck!” she whimpered once more as Brian penetrated her again hard, making her arch her back, and she squirted again as her legs trembled. She let out a shriek, squirting one last time, then continued to squirm and shake as she came hard on her brother’s cock.

“Holy shit!” Tom called out as he turned his head just in time to see Beth squirt with her brother fucking her. He shoved his dick into Kelly, his eyes still on Beth and Brian and his eyes grew wider as Beth squirted again, her body shaking. He thrust himself into Kelly’s tight pussy, watching Beth cum, then he too started cumming.

“Ugh god!” Kelly moaned as she felt Tom’s cock twitch inside her sooner than she would have liked. She was also watching Beth squirt, getting so turned on, and a moment later she felt her boyfriend shoot his first load deep inside her cunt. “Yes, baby!” Kelly moaned as Tom came inside her. “Yes, cum inside me! Fill me up!” she urged kinkily, hearing him groan behind her, and felt his dick continue to throb inside her, squirting his warm cum deep inside her pussy. He kept groaning as he thrust, a deep primal sound of pleasure with each thrust. He pushed himself into her again and again, then pushed himself deep inside her, stretching her twat and held himself in place. His cock twitched a final time, squirting one last load, then he went still, panting behind her.

Jimmy moved his gaze from a squirting Beth and watched Kelly getting filled up with cum next to him. He was so turned on but didn’t want to cum just yet, so he slowed down and savored the sensation, slowly milking his rock-hard dick as he looked at her naked body. He ran his eyes along her body, her pussy barely visible, then up her flat stomach, sexy tits, until he looked up at her face. He caught her gaze, her eyes moving to his, then a wicked grin spread across her lips.

“Jimmy, you wanna fuck me too?” Kelly whispered to him, looking down at his erection as she felt Tom’s member growing soft inside of her.

“What?” Jimmy asked confused, still tugging on his cock slowly.

“You want to feel my pussy around your cock?” Kelly asked again, her voice low and sexy. Jimmy nodded, still not sure, and a smile spread across Kelly’s lips. “Yeah?” she asked smiling, feeling so naughty, then straightened up. Tom pulled his cock out of her, pulling back, and Kelly could feel their combined juices leaking out of her. She turned around to look at Tom, then pressed her lips to his. She gave him a tender kiss, then moved her lips to his ear and whispered, “I’m going to let Jimmy fuck me”.

Beth whimpered as her brother pounded her pussy, again and again, embarrassingly making her squirt.