Substitute dad pt.3

Last we spoke, Todd had just fucked his step-daughter Nicole

Todd looked over his shoulder to see Michelle slumbering peacefully next to him.
What the hell? Did I drink too much yesterday and black out? Was that just an incredibly vivid dream?
Michelle stirred and opened her eyes, smiling up at him.
“Good morning. How did you sleep?”
“Umm, fine.” Todd wasn’t sure what else to say.
“You haven’t had such a peaceful night’s sleep in I don’t know how long. Having sex with Nicole certainly agrees with you.”
Todd stared at her dumbly.
So that was real?
“I don’t know what to say…..” he muttered.
She smiled at him and leaned forward to grab his hand reassuringly.
“Todd, it’s okay. I set it up. I’m not angry or upset. In fact, I’m relieved.”
Todd still couldn’t quite grasp the situation.
“You set me up with your daughter….”
Michelle smiled at him.
“Todd, I’ve never been a very sexual person. When Gene and I divorced, I was trying so hard to prove that it wasn’t my fault that I slept with anyone who showed an interest, and even seduced several men who weren’t interested in me, ruining two of my best friends’ marriages in the process.”
Michelle sat up and continued her story.
“After we got married, I realized that I didn’t have to keep impressing you with my sexuality, and I guess I just got comfortable. I know that isn’t fair to you, and I’m sorry.”
“So you try to make up for it by letting me sleep with Nicole?”
“Not quite make up for it, more like, trying to provide an outlet for your needs.”
Todd couldn’t quite see the connection she was making.
“So you don’t find me attractive anymore …..” He trailed off.
“Todd, I love you. And the thing that I treasure most about our marriage is the companionship. Having you to share my life with makes me feel complete. The thing is, sex isn’t very much of a need for me. But it is for you. So think of Nicole as a sex surrogate.”
Todd was still unsure. “Michelle, we don’t have to do this, we can go to counseling.”
“This is a lot cheaper, and gets the same result.”
“And how will all this affect Nicole? I’ll be using her for sex.”
Michelle smiled.
“She knows that, and is okay with it. I’m afraid that the divorce left her with some daddy issues, and I’m hoping that this will resolve them.”
Todd was incredulous.
“You think that having sex with me will resolve her daddy issues? Are you nuts?!?!?”
“Not at all. Nicole has sex with men because she’s seeking their approval, and then she gets clingy, which drives them away. Having sex just for the fun of it will be a healthy alternative, and help her have more normal relationships.”
Todd shook his head. “You’re grasping at straws here, Michelle. When did you become a licensed therapist?”
Michelle glared at him. “I got my psychology degree!” She snapped.
“Over twenty years ago ….” Todd muttered, but decided to let it slide.
“So how would this work?”
Michelle was still miffed, but slightly mollified, now that Todd seemed to be on board.
“Whenever you’re horny, you fuck Nicole, then you come to bed when you’re done.”
“So what if I’m horny and she isn’t around?”
“You’ll have to wait, unless someone else is available whom I approve of.”
“I’m still trying to picture this. So we go out for a nice romantic evening, we get home, you go to bed, and I go to Nicole’s room?”
“That’s about it. But I still wouldn’t mind a little kissing and cuddling before you go fuck her.”
Todd shook his head in disbelief, but knew that arguing with Michelle over this was a losing battle; she had already made up her mind.
“Where is she now?”
“She went home last night.”
“And you came back to come to bed with me?”
“Yes. Like I said, I enjoy the companionship. I don’t feel right sleeping without you.”
They continued discussing it, and while Todd wasn’t exactly sure about how it would all work out, he had at least agreed to give it a try.
When they arrived home, he immediately went looking for Nicole, and found her by the pool.
“How do you feel today?” She asked him.
“A little unsure about this whole arrangement.” He confessed. “Nicole, why did you agree to this?”
“Because I want to help you guys out. And because I’ve had a crush on you for ages. And because last night was incredible, and no one has ever made me feel that way.”
“Nicole, I’m really concerned about how this is going to affect you. How it affects your relationship with me, and how it affects your relationship with your mom, and how it affects your mom’s and my relationship.”
“I don’t see any reason to worry,” she replied. “We’re all adults, and we all know exactly what we’re getting into.”
Todd seriously doubted that Nicole had any idea what she was getting into.
“Nicole, I would just be using you for sex. I would be out with your mom, come have sex with you, and then leave you and go back to her. How is that going to make you feel, me treating you like that?”
“Mom thinks that it will be good for me. Just fucking, rather then using sex to keep guys from leaving me will help me develop a healthier outlook towards my relationships.”
Todd snorted. “That’s your mother talking. I would be treating you like a prostitute, except I wouldn’t be paying you.”
“No you wouldn’t.” Michelle had walked out and found them. “Because you love her. That’s the difference. You wouldn’t do anything to hurt her.”
Todd turned to face her. “Michelle, I’m afraid that this little experiment will wind up hurting her.”
“And that’s why it will work. Because you are aware of that possibility and will prevent it from happening.”
Todd knew that there was no winning this argument with Michelle.
Michelle sat down next to Nicole and addressed her directly.
“Todd and I have already discussed the rules for this, and I want you to hear them as well. First of all, no kissing.”
“It’s a little late for that, mom.”
Michelle arched an eyebrow. “Really? Well no kissing from now on.”
“Second, Todd has to initiate the sex, you can’t come onto him when you’re feeling horny. And when he’s done, he’s coming to bed with me.”
Nicole nodded, and Todd figured that he’d better make a few more things clear.
“Michelle, why don’t you explain what Nicole is supposed to be getting out of this, just so there’s no misunderstandings.”
Michelle nodded. “Sweetie, you’re going to enjoy sex, purely for the physical pleasure. It’s not something that you use to hold onto a guy. There’s no emotional attachment in this case.”
Todd raised an eyebrow at that, and Michelle wavered a bit.
“Alright, I suppose there is an emotional attachment already, but not a relationship. But you understand that Todd loves me, and is mine.