Sisters By The Pool Part 9

[This is a shorter chapter and I’m looking for thoughts on where to go next. I can either continue the cheer party, have Danielle get involved positively or negatively, or move on soon. Looking for girls to role play and dirty talk with too. Thanks for reading!]

After my glorious weekend with Danielle and Hailey at the hotel, it was time to return to reality. The prospects of another week of School seemed overwhelming, especially since I had not even considered homework during the trip. I half assed most of the assignments on Sunday night and got as much sleep as I could.

I had to admit, I was even more preoccupied than usual. Hailey had done an incredible job managing to stay sexually engaged with me, constantly finding loopholes around her sister’s rules. I pretty much considered Danielle my girlfriend, but there was no doubting that this was a weird situation. It was an amazing one, but not without its awkwardness. I knew things couldn’t stay this perfect forever, so I made it a point to enjoy things as long as they lasted.

But there was a situation to deal with. Hailey had whispered something to me before I left to return home on Sunday night. It was something that I knew would come back around again, and something that was going to divide my internal thoughts to the most extreme level.

It was time for another cheerleader party. That coming weekend, Hailey confirmed that there would be another slumber party, although the location had not been decided yet. She had kind of hinted to me that it was up to me. Everyone had so much fun at the last one, that if I decided to make myself available, the girls had no problem with another night at Hailey’s house. If I wasn’t going to get involved, it would probably end up being another girl’s turn to host.

The original cheerleader slumber party was probably the greatest night of my existence. I lost count how many girls I filled up and the experience of feeling so many different tight, Young girls on me was incredible. I couldn’t even hide my arousal at the thought of experiencing all of that again.

However, on the other hand, there was Danielle to consider. She had been an amazing sport when it came to sexual exploits with her sister, although she hadn’t exactly not enjoyed things. In fact, seeing her in the hotel room with her sister the other night had me briefly thinking of inviting her to the cheerleader party. But how in the world would I broach that subject?

“Hey Danielle,” I could picture myself starting. “As long as you’ve been so cool including your sister in our sexual games, how would you feel about adding another half dozen girls to the equation?”

No, I couldn’t do that. I had every intention of making my times with Danielle special, regardless of what my decision was. I lusted after Hailey and her cheerleader friends, but I really cared about Danielle on an emotional level. What we had was different.

Still, I couldn’t help but think back to that night. I pictured Alana and her incredible rack. I remembered how cute Melanie was, both times that I had fucked her. All of the girls were so gorgeous, and if I was to go wild and crazy one more time, it was hard to think this wasn’t the time.

“So what’s going on this weekend?” I asked Danielle on Thursday afternoon, still undecided on the weekend’s plan.

“I’m not sure,” she started, dressed in a blue t-shirt and jeans. “I’ve been kind of neglecting my girl friends lately.”

“You can see them,” I started. “Obviously I want to hang out with you every day, but you can’t lose your friends.”

She nodded. “You sure you don’t mind?”

“Of course not,” I smiled. I still wasn’t sure what my choice was, but this at least made things easier on me.

I went home on Thursday night and had the internal debate. Finally, I settled on texting Hailey. I knew she wasn’t the most impartial judge, but it couldn’t hurt.

“What do you think?” was all I wrote.

After a few minutes I got a response.

“Look, I know you are conflicted. I know you like my sister. I can’t tell you what to do. But you’re young and it’s not like you two have been very exclusive lately. Remember last weekend. ;)”

She was right. The threesomes with her sister didn’t scream exclusivity. Still, there’s no way she would be cool with these extra extra-curriculars. When it came right down to it, I was still young, still had a lot of time to settle down, but these opportunities weren’t going to last forever.

“Invite them” I sent back to her, and then went to sleep.

…

Danielle had made plans for a big girls night out, though I didn’t know whether it was going to be an all-night thing. Though I felt guilty, I was full of excitement as I made my way to Hailey’s house. I was dressed pretty simply, just wearing a t-shirt and shorts, and had a swim suit with me. I knocked on the door and Hailey opened it with a giant smile. She gave me a huge bear hug.

“This is going to be so much fun,” she said. “Everyone was so excited to hear you were coming.” Hailey was wearing tight, yoga shorts, which shaped her butt perfectly. She caught me staring and shook her ass at me with a wink.

“You can touch,” she laughed. “I won’t tell anything that happens tonight.”

I let my hands explore a little, but didn’t want to get too riled up already.