Sisters By The Pool Part 13

The situation was almost perfect at this point.

I had an incredibly gorgeous girl, who I was more or less dating. Not only that, but I also had permission from her that I could fool around with her equally gorgeous younger sister. It was a fantasy that most people wouldn’t allow themselves to dream about, and I had it. And, yet, I still wasn’t satisfied.

I know, it was horrible of me. I deserved to lose everything I had with this situation. The cheer parties were one thing, but I really had developed a little thing for Melanie. There was something about her, about how badly she wanted me, even needed me. Obviously, she was young, fit and very sexy, but as I mentioned, I had those bases covered twofold already. But, here I was, lying in bed at night, kept up by thoughts of Melanie.

I looked over at my alarm clock. Two in the morning. At least tomorrow was Saturday, so I could sleep in if I had to. Still, I wasn’t going to get much sleep at this rate. I got up and grabbed my phone, flipping through the contacts. I didn’t know if it would be better to talk to Hailey or Melanie, herself, right now. Just for kicks, I pushed the call button on Melanie’s number, and nearly jumped when the ringing stopped after two.

“Hey!” she said, cheerfully, but with a hint of the rasp you hear from someone who was sleeping.

“Hi Melanie, did I wake you?” I asked.

“Oh don’t worry” she giggled. “What’s up?”

“I have to tell you something” I started. “Danielle and I talked, as you know. She was pretty understanding. She even said part of the problem was her fault, for nights with Hailey.”

“Well that’s lucky” Melanie laughed.

“But…” I started. “She isn’t really cool with anything else. She wasn’t happy about the cheer party. Obviously, I don’t blame her for that.”

“Oh…” Melanie started, her mood dampening a little. “Well, yeah, when you said she wanted to talk to you today, I figured that was about it for our fun. I’m really glad we got to play around for a while. You’re a really nice guy and you made me feel good about myself.”

I felt horrible. She was basically crying.

“Melanie, it isn’t just that simple” I continued. “I know I have more going for me right now than most guys could ever hope. I’ve been lying awake tonight because I can’t really stop thinking about you.”

“Really?” she said, more excitedly than I had ever heard her, though with sniffling mixed in.

“This is so complicated” I proceeded. “I really like Danielle. I really like Hailey. And, yes, I really like you. I don’t know what to do.”

There was some silence. I let out a few long sighs as I thought about the situation.

“Look, whatever you do is fine with me” she started normally, before shifting her voice into a seductive whisper. “You just feel so good inside me and I want you.”

“Melanie!” I laughed. “You can’t do that right now.”

“Let me know when you’re ready baby” she continued in her whisper before giggling and switching back to normal. “I’m sorry, I’ll stop.”

“So what are you doing tomorrow?” I asked.

“I just have cheer practice in the early afternoon” she responded.

“Want to come over after?” I asked. I knew it was stupid but I was busy thinking of her talking in that voice in her cheer outfit.

“Really?” she giggled excitedly.

“Yes, just make sure to keep your outfit on” I chuckled.

“Anything for you” she said. “See you tomorrow then!”

Just call me Mr. Greed. I really needed to look into something to lower my sex drive. At least my mind was cleared and I was able to relax a little more. Soon after, I fell asleep, finally.

When I woke, the sun was out. I cursed when I saw the clock read noon. I jumped in the shower and got dressed, knowing I could hear from Melanie at any time. With my parents out of town for the weekend, I had once less thing to worry about.