Sisters By The Pool Part 10

[Thank you to everyone who commented ideas on my last chapter. You gave me motivation for a quick turnaround time and one of my favorite chapters yet. Thanks all for reading!]

The one thing that I had really commended Hailey for throughout the duration of this crazy relationship was her ability to constantly get around her sister’s desires to have me to herself. Whether it was getting her sister to leave the house, or sneaking a quick session underneath the water or behind a bed, Hailey was the master of not getting caught. I had told her that if she tried this hard at school she’d be a future Ivy League student, but I guess this was more important to her.

That’s why, as I finished cumming inside Maddie, my third girl of the night, my thoughts really weren’t on Danielle. I knew that she was doing something with her girl friends that night, and I imagined Hailey was taking care of any loose ends. I had six gorgeous and naked cheerleaders surrounding me, and that’s all I really was thinking about for the time being.

Feeling left out of the festivities so far, Alana and Ashley, the two captains of the cheer team, had formed a very arousing 69. Alana was on top, her red hair cascading onto Ashley’s thighs, while her large breasts pressed against Ashley’s body. Underneath, Ashley was largely out of sight, but her face remained buried between Alana’s legs, furiously working at her clit. Once again, the crisp night air was filled with moans as the two girls brought each other up and down the pleasure scale.

I watched from between Hailey and Melanie, my cum still dripping from both of their pussies. It was a much needed break from a crazy night that seemingly had just begun.

Suddenly I heard what sounded like the closing of a car door. I quickly looked at Hailey, my eyes somewhat wide, but she just smiled at me and looked back to the girls. My heart skipped a beat as I wondered if Danielle could possibly be home already. There was nothing I could do at this point anyway, so I just tried to calm down and prayed that it was a neighbor.

“What the fuck?!” I heard shrieked from a number of yards away. I didn’t even need to look up, knowing that the jig was up. I was in the middle of my second cheerleader slumber party, not to mention the multiple rendezvous with Hailey and Melanie.

I was waiting for Hailey to freak out, the thought of her own fun being put in jeopardy. But surprisingly she didn’t say anything in response.

“Really?” Danielle said again. I looked up and saw her in a small black dress. She looked gorgeous and I didn’t know what to say. I had such an incredible situation going on and I couldn’t wrap my head around Danielle being pissed at me.

The other girls were sitting there with awkward faces. Alana and Ashley had, begrudgingly curtailed their activities. Just as I was about to stand up and say something, I saw Hailey start to move.

“You couldn’t expect to keep this stud locked up forever sis,” Hailey started.

“Shut up Hailey,” Danielle said sternly. “I can expect a little more trust and loyalty than this.”

“It’s not all his fault,” Hailey started to plead my case for me. “I begged him to come to this because I’ve been so nervous of not fitting in with the team. You’ve shared him with me more than once. You can’t blame him for not knowing what the rules were.”

“Hailey,” I started. “Thank you but I should probably defend myself here. Danielle, you know I care about you so much. I knew this was wrong, but I’m young and stupid. I know you don’t want to hear about how impossible a situation like this is for a guy. We’ve already discussed that a mutual attraction exists between me and your sister.”

“Plus,” Hailey jumped in again. “Don’t pretend like you don’t like girls too. You probably haven’t even confessed how bi you are.”

“So I’ve hooked up with a few girls in the past,” Danielle retorted. “Not lately.”

Danielle and Hailey traded meaningful glances, knowing that technically they had recently hooked up, at least for the purposes of being with me. Danielle looked as though she wanted to say something, but couldn’t really figure out how to put it. Her mood had seemingly softened from the beginning of the encounter, and I could only hope that there was a way out of this.

“Well girls, I brought her here,” Hailey started. “Trust me, she wants it. The rest is up to you.”

I looked up at Danielle with a shocked look, and she returned the surprised look as if to say she had no idea what was going on. Just then, Alana and Ashley got up and came over to Danielle.

“What the fuck,” Danielle started, looking a little frightened. “Hailey you’ve got to be kidding me. I’ll get you in so much trouble.”

“Oh no you won’t,” Hailey said with a laugh. “This is going to be the greatest night of your life.”

Ashley grabbed Danielle’s arms and Alana took her legs, wrestling with her until they had a firm grip. Ashley gave Danielle’s arms to Hailey, who took over holding onto her. At that point, Ashley grabbed the bottom of Danielle’s dress and started to pull it upwards, slowly revealing her. Danielle was cursing, but not screaming to the point of trying to alert neighbors to trouble.