Girls First Time Being Shared

This is my husband’s story, and I always thought it was erotic, so I’m going to share it. Peter (my husband) has had hotwife fetishes for a long time now, it was one of the things that I loved about him when we met. Anyway, this takes place years before we had met each other, when he was dating a girl named Olivia. Olivia was very inexperienced sexually, only having been with 4 guys prior… and Peter loved the idea of raising those numbers. He had talked to her about how much it would turn him on for her to fuck other guys, but she was very reluctant and told him she didn’t have any interest in other guys.

He started taking about her letting others see her naked while he fucked her, and it was obvious by her bodies response that she liked it… but outside of the bedroom she would say it was just dirty talk, and she would never do that. Peter eventually started ramping up the “dirty talk” during sex, and would talk about her getting fucked by strangers or one of his friends… once again it became apparent she was slowly starting to like thinking about it, but she still wouldn’t entertain the idea outside of the bed. She told him that her body was special and she only shares it with those she loves. He worked hard to get her to see that it didn’t have to be a big deal… that she could be a little naughty, or have sex just for fun… but she was very resistant to see it that way.

As the months went on she would start making up scenarios during sex, and Peter knew she was starting to grow on the idea… but when he would suggest actually setting something up she would still remain hesitant and insist its only pillow talk. After about a year of dating, Peter started to lose hope that she would ever fulfill his fantasy, and she would only play along while they were fucking. She was a very attractive girl, big breasts, a little shape but not fat… probably around 5’6… very cute, but also a bit shy… unless she gets to know you, or she’s had some drinks in her. She got along with all of Peter’s friends, and would even role play sexual interactions with them while fucking Peter… which Peter loved. He loved the idea that his innocent little girlfriend would allow any or all of his friends to use her body… that she would cum while riding their cocks. Peter thought about it often, and was determined to make something happen.

Olivia received an email saying an old friend from high school was getting married in New York, and despite not being that close to her still wanted to go, knowing that a lot of her old friends would be there. Flight tickets and hotels weren’t cheap, so she was going to try to arrive the day off and leave the next day… but Peter showed her that it was actually cheaper to leave two days before. Olivia brought up that would mean more nights in a hotel, which would be more expensive… but Peter got an idea that made him feel like the stars had aligned. “I can ask Blake if he wouldn’t mind you crashing at his house… you guys always got along well, I’m sure he wouldn’t mind” he told her and waited for her reaction. Olivia thought about it for a second and responded “it would probably be awkward, just the two of us… I would feel like I’m imposing”. Peter scoffed and said “I’ll text him and see what he’s up to, and see how he’d feel about it”.

Olivia had met Blake early on in the relationship, but he moved away to New York for business. He was often brought up during their “pillow talk”, and she knew what Peter was hoping for. She told Peter “I know what you’re thinking, but I’m not going to fuck him”. Peter, trying to play it cool, said “I know, just trying to help you out… although if you wanted to have any sexy fun while there, I’ll be happy to allow it… with or without Blake”. Olivia smirked and said “Don’t hold your breath… besides, Blake has a girlfriend already and probably wouldn’t be interested anyway, so it doesn’t matter”. That statement made Peter think that Olivia was maybe thinking about it, and it made his dick hard immediately. Peter kissed her and said “I think that would be so sexy… letting him have you”, as he picked her up and carried her into the bedroom. They role-played him being Blake a she allowed him to use her pussy, her calling out his name as she told him to “Fuck me, Blake… do you like my titties… do you like stroking inside my wet cunt, Blake?”.

Afterwards she would insist that she only said those things as a fantasy, and she would never actually do it… but Peter was starting to feel like there was a chance. He talked to Blake who said he was happy to take her in and show her around the city while she was there. Peter asked Blake if his girlfriend would mind, and Blake responded “we’re on again, off again all the time… I’ll just make sure we’re off again while Olivia’s here to avoid drama”. Peter decided he was going to tell him what he was hoping would happen… that he wanted Blake to seduce his girlfriend while she was with him. Blake kind of chuckled and said “I’m not going to lie, I was kind of thinking about doing that anyway… but I didn’t want to make things awkward between you and I if I did”. Peter laughed and asked “you were going to try to fuck my girlfriend?”, to which Blake responded “the thought had run across my mind…